A Brief History of Moral Theology
John Mahoney in “The Making of Moral Theology” argues that since the 6th century Christians have associated moral theology with sin.
13th Century- Pope Innocent III, requires annual confession
- Dominicans were to hear confessions as their mission
- Dominicans were thus required to attend lectures on confessions
- Output: Summaries of confessional manuals
- "Penitentials"
16th Century- Age characterised by Expansionism
- Moralists concerned with what is sin, what is not.
- Particular issues related to the age: lending practices, investments
- These judgments were collated into textbooks: the textbooks have lasted until Vatican II
- Sin-centred
17th Century- No major changes: moralists were convinced that the task of moral theology was solely to teach the priest how to determine in confession what was sin and its due penance
- This cuts the first principle of natural law in half: instead of "avoid evil and do good" the bias focused on avoiding evil
Early 20th Century- Manuals of moral theology appear in the vernacular
- Aside: material on the 6th commandment in Latin so as not be an occasion for sin for the reader.